I just discovered that there is a second aiptasia on the same rock! I was going to remove the rock, so that I could get them off LFS said you could take the rock off under their base, and you will get the whole thing. I looked, and unfortunately I placed that one rock as the support for almost all my other live rock, so he promised me a bottle of Joe's Juice from his next shipment in a couple of weeks. It seems a little easier to handle than Kalkwasser. Thanks for all the help everyone
